This Is The Absolute Best Vanilla Ice Cream You Can Buy At The Store

We tested a lot of ice cream to choose the winner.

by
Scoop of vanilla ice cream drizzle with fudge

Eat it plain, or drizzle with hot fudge. Photo, Roberto Caruso.

It’s finally ice cream season. While there are plenty of places across Canada that sell over-the-top ice cream cones with toppings like cotton candy, activated charcoal sauce and even 24-karat gold leaf, sometimes it’s nice to go back to basics.

The current vanilla shortage is all the Chatelaine food team has been reading and thinking about these days (we love to bake!). Since we were craving this classic flavour, we decided to hold a blind taste test to determine the absolute best store-bought vanilla ice cream in Canada (tubs found in the freezer section of big-box grocery stores — for that reason, we excluded some delicious regional products). So without further ado, here’s the scoop.

The great lactose-free ice cream option

Tub of lactose-free vanilla ice cream.

Deliciously lactose-free. Photo, Natrel.

There are plenty of vegan options of supermarket shelves these days, but few for those who love dairy, but can’t eat it. Natrel recently introduced a line of lactose-free flavours, including vanilla. It stood its ground next to the conventional offerings thanks to its rich vanilla bean flavour. It works on its own or as an accompaniment to a more decadent dessert.

The indulgent choice

Tub of PC black menu vanilla ice cream.

Unadulterated vanilla flavour. Photo, President’s Choice.

One scoop of President’s Choice Black Label Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla ice cream is more than enough, though this is the one you’d want to eat on its own. With a pale golden colour, this luxurious custardy treat might come off as a bit sweet, but you’ll get a bold hit of vanilla with each spoonful. (This one was the winner to me, but alas, I got out-voted.)

The nostalgic classic

Salted caramel ice cream bars

Making ice cream sandwiches is easy with Chapman’s. Photo, Erik Putz.

If you’re itching to make ice cream sandwiches or milkshakes, turn to Chapman’s — it’s simple and straightforward and won’t overwhelm whatever you eat it with. Food director Sue Riedl found Chapman’s vanilla nostalgic, reminding her of the scoops you’d find at a country general store. Best of all, this Canadian brand’s bricks of vanilla ice cream are perfect for slicing, which means making dessert with it is a breeze.

The Winner: The best vanilla ice cream

Tub of Haagen-Dazs vanilla ice cream,

It’s a classic. Photo, Häagen-Dazs.

Häagen-Dazs vanilla ice cream is a classic for a reason. And it came out on top thanks to its creamy texture and solid vanilla flavour. “It’s not a showstopper, but a great classic vanilla,” says associate food editor Emily Kichler. If you’re eating something à la mode, go for Häagen-Dazs — it would taste great atop a summery fruit pie.

Watch: How to make ice cream sandwiches